2010 Outer Critics Circle Award Nominations
Outstanding New Off-Broadway Musical (tie)
Outstanding New Score
Outstanding Director of a Musical - Alex Timbers
Outstanding Set Design - Donyale Werle
Outstanding Lighting Design - Justin Townsend
2010 Drama Desk Award Nominations
Outstanding Book of a Musical - Alex Timbers
Outstanding Music - Michael Friedman
2010 Drama League Award Nominations
Distinguished Production of a Musical
Distinguished Performance, Benjamin Walker
2011 Tony Award Nominations
Best Book of a Musical
Best Scenic Design of a Musical